Stop the destruction of Borneo's proboscis monkey forest!

To: Lim Ming Seong, Chairman, Ciliandra Fangiono and Fang Zhixiang, CEO First Resources Ltd

“Stop the destruction of the proboscis monkey forest”

Read letter

To: Lim Ming Seong, Chairman, Ciliandra Fangiono and Fang Zhixiang, CEO First Resources Ltd

Gentlemen,

I am shocked to learn that the Indonesian company PT Wahana Prima Sejati – a subsidiary of your enterprise First Resources Ltd – has already cleared several dozen hectares of high-biodiversity secondary forest on the eastern coast of Borneo to build to build a palm oil refinery, a biodiesel plant and related infrastructure. First Resources Ltd, as parent company and a leading palm oil plantation operator in Indonesia, is a member of RSPO and pledged to eliminate deforestation and rights abuses from its supply chain already in 2015. As the present case of PT Wahana Prima Sejati alarmingly illustrates, that pledge is not being kept:

Specifically, it is coastal forest at Sanro Mutti Beach (Area Pengunaan Lain) on the eastern coast of Borneo, where several dozen hectares of high conservation value forest have been cleared. The affected area is home to a vital and large population of proboscis monkeys, a species that is classified in the IUCN Red List as endangered. Furthermore, threatened species such as orangutans, clouded leopards, sun bears, hornbills, pangolins and marbled cats have been recorded in that area. While bushfires and deforestation for palm oil plantations have been the biggest threat to these rare animals in the past, the most serious threat now are infrastructure projects for the palm oil industry.

This destruction of high conservation value forest and habitat for threatened proboscis monkeys is a violation of the Principles and Criteria of the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), specifically against the principle of environmental responsibility and conservation of natural resources and biodiversity. Any processing of palm oil in this refinery would not qualify for an RSPO certification. In addition, the deforestation is in breach with your own company’s guidelines.

I therefore urge First Resources Ltd to

1) prevent the building of the refinery by PT Wahana Prima Sejati
2) stop the building of the proposed biodiesel and oleochemical plants
3) arrange for the restoration of the deforested area.

Please pull the emergency brake and make reparations for the damage! I thank you for your efforts in this urgent case.

Yours faithfully,

In 2020, the company PT Wahana Prima Sejati (WPS) cleared 86 hectares of high conservation value rainforest. Local environmentalists filed a formal complaint with the parent company, First Resources. Our petition served to support the complaint.

In 2021, Pro Wildlife, SAVE and Rainforest Rescue protested with an open letter to the RSPO, calling for measures to be taken against First Resources such as a stop to the construction of its processing plants and requiring the land to be reforested.

In response to our criticism, First Resources claimed that the RSPO criteria only apply to oil palm plantations and mills. This case in the forest of the proboscis monkeys thus uncovered a glaring omission in the RSPO’s “principles and criteria”: The RSPO urgently needs to tighten them up to prevent copycats.

Thanks to our petition, protests and the formal objection, First Resources was required to remove its construction machinery in early 2021.

In December 2021, the RSPO adopted a resolution clarifying that the destruction of valuable forests is not only prohibited for oil palm plantations themselves, but that this also applies to the entire production chain, including processing plants and refineries.

In 2022, the company resumed clearing forest. We immediately alerted the RSPO, but more public pressure is needed.

In 2023, the Minister of Investment announced that Indonesia is planning a general amnesty for all illegal oil palm plantations. It would apply to around 1,200 plantations for which 3.4 million hectares of forest were illegally cleared. First Resources would also remain unpunished if the amnesty were to become legally binding.

News · Aug 25, 2021

Malaysia: logjam triggers environmental disaster

Even seasoned environmental activists were shocked by the scale of this disaster: A logjam has been clogging the Baleh River in the Malaysian state of Sarawak for days. Dead fish, a drowned deer and thousands of tree trunks can be seen in the photos sent by our partner Matek Geram. Loggers along the upper reaches of the river are responsible.

more